Prof. Crowther has criticised the quantity theory of money on the ground that it explains only ‘how it works’ of the fluctuations in the value of money and does not explain ‘why it works’ of these fluctuations. Money is considered neutral and changes in money supply are believed to affect the absolute prices and not relative prices. Money is demanded not for its own sake (i.e., for hoarding it), but for transaction purposes. Criticisms 5. Unrealistic Assumption of full Employment: Keynes’ fundamental criticism of the quantity theory of money was based upon its unrealistic assumption of fall employment. Fisher’s quantity theory is best explained with the help of his famous equation of exchange. The truth of this proposition is evident from the fact that if M and M’ are doubled, while V, V and T remain constant, P is also doubled, but the value of money (1/P) is reduced to half. Fisher’s quantity theory of money is explained with the help of Figure 1. Price curve, P = f(M), is a 45° line showing a direct proportional relationship between the money supply and the price level. 500, V = 3, V’ = 2, T = 4000 goods. In his theory of demand for money, Fisher attached emphasis on the use of money as a medium of exchange. In a self-adjusting free-market economy in which changes in money supply do not affect the real macro variables of employment and output, there is little room left for a monetary policy. The equation of exchange is an identity equation, i.e., MV is identically equal to PT (or MV = PT). (iii) P Influences T – Fisher assumes price level (P) as a passive factor having no effect on trade (T). The quantity theory of money depends on the simple fact that if people will be having more money then they will want to spend more and that means more people will bid for the same goods/services and that will cause the price to shoot up. No Direct and Proportionate Relation between M and P: Keynes criticised the classical quantity theory of money on the ground that there is no direct and proportionate relationship between the quantity of money (M) and the price level (P). 4000 to 2000, the price level is halved, i.e., from 1 to 1/2, and the value of money is doubled, i.e., from 1 to 2. The relative (or real) prices are determined in the commodity markets and the absolute (or nominal) prices in the money market. When the quantity of money is M1 the value of money is 1/P. By My Assignment Help 2. Moreover, the volume of transactions T is also affected by changes in P. When prices rise or fall, the volume of business transactions also rises or falls. Uploader Agreement. The theory forms the basis of the monetary policy. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Although Fisher Did Not Add To The PPT. Any exploration of the relationship between money and inflation almost necessarily begins with a discussion of the venerable “ quantity theory of money ” (QTM). There is, nevertheless, considerable disagreement over the meaning of this body of analysis. The former is a static concept and the latter a dynamic. Fisher’s theory explains the relationship between the money supply and price level. According to Fisher the price level (P) is a passive factor which means that the price level is affected by other factors of equation, but it does not affect them. Not only this, M and M’ are not independent of T. An increase in the volume of business transactions requires an increase in the supply of money (M and M’). If the money supply increases in line with real output then there will be no inflation. Thus the theory is one-sided. The equation of exchange (MV = PT) is a mere truism and proves nothing. But, in reality, rising prices increase profits and thus promote business and trade. Second, it gives undue importance to the price level as if changes in prices were the most critical and important phenomenon of the economic system. Start studying A2 Economics Macro - 10. Thus, when M’, V, V’ and T in the equation MV + M’Y’ = PT are constant over time and P is a passive factor, it becomes clear, that a change in the money supply (M) will lead to a direct and proportionate change in the price level (P). Fisher's equation of exchange. Each side of the equation gives the money value of total transactions during a period. Account Disable 12. Fisher points out the price level (P) (M+M’) provided the volume of tra remain unchanged. Third, Keynes does not believe that the relationship between the quantity of money and the price level is direct and proportional. But it cannot be accepted today that a certain percentage change in the quantity of money leads to the same percentage change in the price level. (A) and (B). Disclaimer Copyright, Share Your Knowledge
Plagiarism Prevention 5. Irving Fisher and the Quantity Theory of Money: The Last Phase - Volume 22 Issue 3 - Robert W. Dimand. Milton Friedman, the leading monetarist, is of the view that the quantity theory was not given full chance to fight the great depression 1929-33; there should have been the expansion of credit or money or both. This website includes study notes, research papers, essays, articles and other allied information submitted by visitors like YOU. When the total quantity of money is M the general price level is Pi- When the quantity of money increases from M 1 to M 2, the corresponding price level rises from P 1 to P 2.Similarly when the total quantity of money in circulation decreases from M3 to M 1, the price level falls from P 3 to P 1.. 4. Fisher’s quantity theory is best explained with the help of his famous equation of exchange: Like other commodities, the value of money or the price level is also determined by the demand and supply of money. He further supported that the quantity theory of money determines the supply of money and the price level in the economy view the full answer The quantity theory does not explain the process of causation between M and P. The critics regard the quantity theory as redundant and unnecessary. In order to find out the effect of the quantity of money on the price level or the value of money, we write the equation as. The quantity theory of money states that the quantity of money is the main determinant of the price level or the value of money. When the money supply is halved from OM to OM2, the price level is halved from OP to OP2. In its modern form, the quantity theory builds upon the following definitional relationship. Thus, any change in the supply of money (M) will have no effect on T. Constancy of T also means full employment of resources in the economy.